Content in the Archives

Max Lury, No Ghosts

Peninsula Press, 304pp, £12.99, ISBN 9781913512811

reviewed by Thomas Chadwick

Midway through Max Lury’s intelligent and inviting novel No Ghosts, a character called Harlow makes a film. In another novel — from another time — this would be a moment of inspiration: a rush of blood and the jerk of the boom arm as the auteur’s vision is brought to life. Not here. Harlow’s film is constructed from existing digital files that she places in an order she herself does not fully understand. The process does not feel creative, divine inspiration is absent, instead the whole thing is ‘more akin to filing documents.’

A lot of No Ghosts is about filing. The set up is straightforward: Annie goes missing, a year later two of her friends — Harlow and Kieran — try to work out what happened to her — and in so doing perhaps repair a broken friendship. Opportunities for repair prove scant, though, as Harlow and Kieran follow largely different paths.

Harlow has recently quit a company called Horizon whose success with generative video may or may not be built on stolen training data. Her quest is initiated when an image of Annie appears amidst some fragments of video that showed up in her inbox. The fragments turn out to have originated from Horizon who are unsure themselves how they are generated. Harlow ends up moving to Horizon’s headquarters in Scotland to try and figure out the mystery, whether that’s Annie or the fragments or both. Kieran, meanwhile, works in a call centre. His search arrives more obliquely. He spots a camp near Kensal Green Cemetery, he watches an interview with the spokesman for the now disbanded Greater London Union of Neo-Spiritualists, he learns that sightings of ghosts, which only a few years ago were at an all time high, have now disappeared. After watching a documentary, Kieran starts to investigate; attending seances, looking for the missing ghosts — and, possibly, Annie.

The data is different but, over the course of the novel, parallel lines emerge between Harlow and Kieran’s searches. First, the focus on their lost friend Annie drifts in and out of perspective. Both are at times urgent, at others meandering. Both searches demand their attention but also appear as a symptom of a wider boredom within their twenty-first century lives. The reader is never quite sure how invested they are in the search or if they believe they will find anything to do with Annie at all. There are points of intersection: Harlow wonders if while trying to make it as an actress Annie might have done film work for Horizon and her image entered the mysterious training data; Kieran learns that Annie also attended the seances before she disappeared. At other times Annie drifts away. Kieran notes that speaking about Annie at the seances ‘feels artificial’; even the image of Annie in the fragments is not her, but rather ‘how Annie’s face would look if she wore a mask.’

Often it feels as if the quest for Annie has been subsumed into a wider voyage into how memory is made in the rubble of digital culture. This leads to the second parallel: both Kieran and Harlow end up becoming archivists, filing and sorting the data they encounter as part of the search. While Harlow’s search through the fragments leads her to make a film, Kieran ends up secretly transcribing the seances he attends. He eschews the use of software to make the transcription himself, even printing the finished work off and storing it in hardback folders. Through colour coded ring binders the ‘intangible becomes tangible’ and Kieran hopes to hold onto something that had meaning.

Somewhere in amongst the characters’ trawl through oceans of data the straightforward setup of the novel starts to unravel into something more complex and more compelling. It becomes clear that the personal projects undertaken by Kieran and Harlow are being mirrored at wider scales. Harlow meets a filmmaker and discovers she isn’t the only one to see loved ones in the fragments, subsequently she notices a whole roomful of Horizon employees streaming her own edits to the fragmented data. Kieran starts uploading content from his transcriptions to the message system at the call centre only to find that other séance attendees are compiling their own secret transcriptions and uploading them all over London. The data that felt so personal ends up being processed in largely similar ways; as Harlow concludes: ‘[t]he order was not mythical but algorithmic — predetermined in some sun-bleached Californian lab.’

No Ghosts gently coaxes the reader to think about how data is handled and generated in the brave new world of generative AI. The hints are everywhere: obscure data sets used for training models; the censoring of graphic images; new sequences assembled from archives of fragments. The net result, though, is a world in which content is flattened and everything is the same. As Harlow notes: ‘Not all new information was necessarily a surprise.’

Where does that leave the ghosts? If we take the novel’s title literally the answer is simple: there are none; they are lost in the great flattening of meaning and language at the hands of the algorithms and tech bros. A more interesting reading though might be that the ghosts have been displaced into the gaps between digital information. As much as they are searching for traces of their lost friend, Harlow and Kieran appear to be in search of some trace of their lost selves. This is where the novel is at its strongest. Beneath the precise depiction of the frameworks of digital culture is a story about growing up, about how the memories and friendships of early adulthood can quickly fall out of focus, unravel, even haunt.

Thomas Chadwick is the author of the short story collection Above the Fat. His fiction has been shortlisted for the White Review prize and the Galley Beggar Prize. www.thomaschadwick.net