'Thanks': On Negative Criticism

by Orit Gat

The commonplace complaint is that no-one reads reviews anymore, and that reviews sections are consequently a nonissue. But we should read reviews, and we should read them carefully and think about the huge role they play in a magazine. The reviews section in any given publication is oftentimes the largest section and covers a substantial number of artists. It is thus a place where we need to scrutinise representation, but also a place in which a magazine asserts its stakes: if the reviews section is an entryway into the features well, then both the artists covered and the writers assigned may be involved with it more closely in the future. It’s where writers learn to write and where artists often get their first significant bibliographical notation. Lastly, the reviews section has a significant financial role in any given magazine. The fact that advertising and revenue models are changing because of the internet only makes this more crucial. [read full essay]

True Value

Ben Marcus, Leaving the Sea

reviewed by Jake Elliott

Leaving The Sea is only the third offering of Ben Marcus’s fiction we have seen in the UK. 2012 saw the publication of his masterpiece The Flame Alphabet by Granta, who have also had the good sense to republish his earlier work The Age of Wire and String with beautiful illustrations by Catrin Morgan. Given the outstanding quality of his writing, I can only assume that plans are in place to bring Notable American Women to UK readers without forcing them onto the internet and the custom of... [read more]

A Nasty and Brutal Business

Christopher Hale, Massacre in Malaya: Exposing Britain’s My Lai

reviewed by John Newsinger

For many years the British Army had a reputation as experts in counterinsurgency. Whereas both the French and the Americans had suffered humiliating defeats in Indo-China, Algeria and Vietnam, the British had not only successfully crushed insurgencies in Malaya, Kenya and elsewhere, but also managed the task without resorting to the brutality, torture and overkill that discredited other counterinsurgency campaigns. In the 1990s, this reputation was reinforced by the British performance in... [read more]

'I am not a man, I am dynamite'

Peter Sloterdijk, Nietzsche Apostle

reviewed by Stuart Walton

Peter Sloterdijk's Nietzsche, celebrated here in the transcript of a talk given in Weimar on the centenary in 2000 of the German philosopher's death, is first and foremost the iconoclast of language, which is to say of classical philosophical discourse. Standing at the dawn of humanity's plunge into irrationality, he is also the end-result of a tradition of self-assertion that expressed itself through the hubris of nations with regard to their own cultures, and their belligerent intentions... [read more]

It's Time to Start Taking Jane Bowles Seriously

Jane Bowles, Two Serious Ladies

reviewed by Anna Coatman

This February, HarperCollins US published a new edition of Jane Bowles’ 1943 novel Two Serious Ladies. If you’ve never read the book before, I hope this news might prompt you to do so - but please don’t judge it by its cover. The design features an illustration of two young women in 1940s dresses. It’s nice, in its way: pretty, a bit kooky, cute. The thing is, Two Serious Ladies isn’t. The two ladies on the cover (described as being ‘like an ad for Daria’ by the women’s... [read more]

Beauty and Truth

Robert B. Pippin, After the Beautiful: Hegel and the Philosophy of Pictorial Modernism

reviewed by Tom Hastings

If Art really can embody intelligible relations (love, friendship, citizenry) between subjects (you, me, them) and objects (you, me, this) in a way that Philosophy desires to but can’t, how can this mode of comportment be represented? And if we follow the German philosopher Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel in recognising art and philosophy as communicating one recognisably ‘same content’ to a greater or lesser extent, what criteria are available to the enquirer to test this out? Hegel’s... [read more]

The Century's Marginal Spaces

Marco Roth, The Scientists: A Family Romance

reviewed by Dan Barrow

In a 1929 essay, Walter Benjamin writes that ‘the nineteenth century did not reveal itself to Zola or Anatole France, but to the young Proust, the insignificant snob, the playboy and socialite who snatched in passing the most astounding confidences from a declining age... It took Proust to make the nineteenth century ripe for memoirs.’ The reigning peace and ignorance of the aristocratic and bourgeois interiors of the 19th century – the condition, sketched by Benjamin four years later in... [read more]

Something Is At Stake

Gillian Darley and David McKie, Ian Nairn: Words in Place

reviewed by Pete Maxwell

There is a scene from the television series Ian Nairn’s Journeys, the episode where he takes the Orient Express through Europe to its terminus in Istanbul, that everyone familiar with the architecture critic recalls. Nairn has arrived at his first stop, Munich, where he delivers a succinct interpretation of the city from atop the town hall. The camera then switches to a night shot of a fairground ride, a gentle German ballad playing in the background, then to Nairn on the ground, trapped in... [read more]

'There’s more past than present here'

Kamila Shamsie, A God in Every Stone

reviewed by Michael Duffy

In Shame, Salman Rushdie refers to the modern state of Pakistan as a palimpsest – an historical document that is barely legible beneath hundreds of years of writing, erasing and rewriting by various colonising forces, visionary leaders and military dictators. Kamila Shamsie provides another look at that palimpsest in A God in Every Stone, a novel that straddles two historical moments as two archaeologists – a master and her apprentice – look for the hidden layers in colonial Peshawar and... [read more]

Writing, Not Lack

Emma L. Rees, The Vagina: A Literary and Cultural History

reviewed by Jane Cleasby

It is virtually impossible to begin reading Emma L. Rees’ The Vagina: A Literary and Cultural History without the spectre of Naomi Wolf’s 2012 publication – Vagina: A New Biography – hovering over it. That Wolf herself offers the primary quote of praise on the back cover of Rees’ book is cause for trepidation. Thankfully, The Vagina offers none of the narcissistic memoir, dressed up in Cosmo-style, essentialist pseudo-science that is peddled by Wolf: the similarities between their two... [read more]

Free To Do the Right Thing

Daphna Erdinast-Vulcan, Between Philosophy and Literature: Bakhtin and the Question of the Subject

reviewed by Andre van Loon

What kind of people would we like to be? And, perhaps more importantly, how should other people, in an ideal world, behave? Such questions can sustain idle gossip as much as high philosophy, both perhaps driven by a feeling that what happens between us is not quite right. There is always a next time, a chance to do better; the other can be more loving, less disappointing. We – and they – can become more virtuous, more understanding. And we do not need a transcendental God, long dead or... [read more]